Step by Step guide to find your Startup's Valuation

Startup Valuation 101 – Edition #4. Follow the steps to find your companies worth.

Hey founders,

Welcome to another edition of My Unicorn Club - The Startup Newsletter. It's a biweekly FREE newsletter written by those on this side of the table (VCs & Investors) for those on that side (Founders & Startup Enthusiasts).

Last week, we discussed in detail about what are other way of funding and its implication if you are not ready for VC round yet. Read it here

Today we're tackling a question that keeps founders up at night: "How do I know what my startup is actually worth?"

Before we dive in, try this tool to simplify your valuation decisions.

Startup Valuation Calculator

This calculator estimates your startup’s valuation using 5 proven methods—on a single sheet.

What it does:
📌 Projects your revenue, EBITDA, and exit value
📌Compares valuation across Revenue, EBITDA, DCF, LTV, and Cost to Build
📌 Calculates investor returns, IRR, and exit multiples

Why it matters:

• Compare valuation methods side-by-side

• Understand investor ROI before your raise

• Model 5-year financials with zero finance background

• Founder-friendly → Built to remove ambiguity from early-stage fundraising
  

After witnessing founders struggle with valuation discussions—especially when investors throw around terms like "EBITDA multiples" and "comparable company analysis"—I wanted to create a practical guide that helps you understand how your startup gets valued and what drives those numbers.

Whether you're preparing for your first funding round or trying to make sense of a term sheet, understanding valuation fundamentals will make you a more confident negotiator and help you set realistic expectations.

Why Private Company Valuation Matters More Than You Think?

Your startup's valuation isn't just a number that determines how much equity you give up. It affects everything from employee option pools to your ability to raise future rounds. Get it wrong, and you could find yourself with an "impossible" valuation that scares away Series A investors.

The challenge? Unlike public companies with daily stock prices, private companies require detective work to determine value. But once you understand the core methods investors use, you'll be able to speak their language and better prepare for funding conversations.

The Three Types of Private Companies (And Where You Fit)

Before diving into valuation methods, it's crucial to understand that investors approach different types of private companies differently:

• Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises (SMEs):
  These are typically family-owned businesses or small service providers with limited revenue. Their valuations are often based on simple asset or earnings calculations.

• Middle-Market Firms:
  Companies generating $10 million to $1 billion in annual revenue. They have more complex financial structures and usually get valued using EBITDA multiples or industry-specific revenue multiples.

• Large Private Companies:
  These rival public companies in scale—think SpaceX or Stripe before their latest rounds. They get valued like public companies with detailed DCF analyses and market comparables.

Most startups fall into the first category initially, then graduate to the middle market as they scale. Understanding where you fit helps set realistic valuation expectations.

Method 1: Comparable Company Analysis (The Gold Standard)

Think of this like determining your home's value by looking at similar houses that recently sold in your neighborhood. Investors find publicly traded companies that match your startup in industry, size, and growth characteristics.

Here's how it works in practice:

Step 1: Identify Your Peers Let's say you're running a B2B SaaS company. Investors would look at public companies like HubSpot, Salesforce, or Monday.com—focusing on those with similar revenue size, growth rates, and target markets.

Step 2: Calculate Industry Averages. They examine key metrics from these peers:

• Revenue multiples (how many times annual revenue the company is worth)

• EBITDA multiples (for profitable companies)

• Growth rates and customer acquisition costs

• Operating margins and retention rates

Step 3: Apply Adjustments. Here's where it gets interesting. Your private startup will typically get valued at a discount to public peers because:

• Your shares are harder to sell (illiquidity discount of 20-30%)

• You have less access to capital markets

• You may have a more concentrated risk

Example: If public SaaS companies trade at 10x revenue and your startup has $2M in annual recurring revenue, you might expect a baseline valuation of $20M. But after applying a 25% illiquidity discount, you're looking at closer to $15M

Method 2: Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) Analysis

This method asks: "What are the future cash flows of this business worth today?" It's particularly useful for startups with predictable revenue models.

The process involves three key steps:

Step 1: Revenue Forecasting: Investors estimate your growth by examining your historical performance, industry trends, and market size. They're looking for realistic projections, not hockey stick fantasies.

Step 2: Cost Projections: This gets tricky with startups because your accounting might mix personal and business expenses, or you might have inconsistent spending patterns. Investors will "normalize" your financials to get a clearer picture.

Step 3: Calculate Present Value: They take those future cash flows and discount them back to today's dollars using a rate that reflects your business's risk level.

Startup Reality Check: Most early-stage companies have negative cash flows, making DCF analysis less relevant. But if you're profitable or approaching profitability, this method becomes crucial for Series A+ rounds.

What Drives Your Valuation Multiple?

Understanding these factors helps you prepare for investor conversations and identify areas to strengthen before fundraising:

• Size Matters: Larger companies get higher multiples because they're seen as more stable. A $10M revenue SaaS company will trade at a higher multiple than a $1M revenue one, even with similar growth rates.

• Revenue Stability: Consistent, predictable revenue gets rewarded. Monthly recurring revenue from annual contracts beats sporadic project-based income every time.

• Customer Diversification: If your top customer represents 30% of revenue, expect a valuation discount. Investors worry about concentration risk and the potential for business disruption.

• Growth Potential: Strong, sustainable growth can justify premium valuations. But investors are increasingly skeptical of "growth at any cost" models—they want to see a path to profitability.

• Competitive Moats: Intellectual property, network effects, or high switching costs can boost your multiple by creating barriers to competition.

Common Valuation Mistakes Founders Make

Mistake #1: Cherry-Picking Comparables Don't compare your pre-revenue startup to Salesforce. Pick realistic peers based on stage, not aspirations.

Mistake #2: Ignoring Market Conditions. Valuations fluctuate dramatically based on interest rates, market sentiment, and industry trends. A multiple that worked in 2021 might be 50% lower today.

Mistake #3: Overweighting One Method. Smart investors use multiple valuation approaches and look for convergence. If comparable analysis says $10M but DCF suggests $5M, there's probably a reality check needed.

Mistake #4: Forgetting About Dilution. A higher valuation today might hurt future fundraising if you can't grow into it. Sometimes, taking a lower valuation with better terms is the smarter long-term play.

Practical Action Steps for Your Next Funding Round

Before You Start Fundraising:

1. Download Startup Valuation Calculator. What does it do?

   1. Forecasts your revenue, EBITDA, and exit value

   2. Benchmarks valuation using Revenue, EBITDA, DCF, LTV, and Cost to Build

   3. Calculates investor returns, IRR, and exit multiples

2. Research 5-7 truly comparable public companies and track their key metrics

3. Clean up your financials and separate personal from business expenses

4. Prepare 3-year financial projections with clear assumptions

5. Identify your key value drivers and areas of competitive advantage

During Investor Conversations:

1. Ask investors to explain their valuation methodology

2. Understand what comparables they're using and why

3. Discuss how they view your growth potential and risk factors

4. Get clarity on any discounts they're applying and their reasoning

Red Flags to Watch For:

• Investors who won't explain their valuation process

• Valuations that seem disconnected from market reality

• Heavy focus on revenue multiples for unprofitable companies without clear paths to profitability

The Bottom Line on Startup Valuation

Valuation is part art, part science, and heavily influenced by market timing. The key is understanding how investors think about value so you can prepare accordingly and negotiate from a position of knowledge.

Remember: the "right" valuation isn't always the highest one. It's the one that reflects your current reality while leaving room for future growth without creating an impossible bar for your next round.

Quick favor: If this breakdown was helpful, could you forward it to one founder friend who's thinking about fundraising? These conversations are always easier when you understand the language investors speak.

---

Until next time, keep building!

Sayanee Bhowmik

P.S. Forward this to any founder friends who might be fundraising—they'll appreciate the clarity.

Resources:

• Startup Valuation Calculator (5 valuation Methods)

• Pre-Money ↔ Post-Money Calculator

• Complete Fundraising Kit

  If you like reading My Unicorn Club - The Startup Newsletter - spread the word and share it with someone who might need it :)